Academic Lead (MMU): Dr Ornette D Clennon
Related Post
Black Lawyers Matter, West Indian Sports and Social Club, Westwood Street, Moss Side, 5.5.16 UPDATED
Last night’s Black Lawyers Matter event doubled up as a launch of the new Lemn Sissay Bursaries and a progress update of work done on the initiative since last year.
Read more, here.
Here are some discussion points from the public meeting, with my commentaries:
Just at Black Lawyers Matter, Lemn Sissay bursary launch! pic.twitter.com/tO4TIDK8Uu
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Dr Dawn Edge giving an update of activities from our last community meeting . pic.twitter.com/VhMr8u6J4c
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Community-University Partnerships
#blacklawyersmatter Dawn Edge: Community university partnerships. The need4different dialogues and ending cultural stereotypes
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Dawn Edge: More than recruitment, need to think about progression. University culture, brutalising, very white. Sys not set up4 BAME
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Dawn Edge: Will talk about UoM activities. #blacklawyersmatter
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
This is an extremely interesting point because the dynamic between universities and communities is very complex and multifaceted. As mentioned, the brutalising nature of academia can be traced to its transactions of whiteness within the academy, where black bodies (staff and students) are made to feel alien or like invaders. The AHRC-funded Common Cause project explores some of these issues.
Related Research
Kagan, C., Lawthom, R., Clennon, O.D., Fisher, J., Diamond, J. & Goldstraw, K. (2017) ‘Sustainable Communities: University-Community Partnership Research on Social Dimensions of Sustainable Development’. In W. Leal (Ed.), Sustainable Development Research at Universities in the United Kingdom. (pp.245 – 262) New York: Springer
Clennon, O.D. (2014) What’s education for, privilege or meritocracy? openDemocracyUK [website] May 21, 2014, Available at: here. [Accessed: 21.5.14]
Clennon, O.D. (2013) Anyone, for a delicious slice of pineapple upside-down cake? National Coordinating Centre for Public Engagement (NCCPE) [blog] December 18, 2013, Available at: here. [Accessed: 18.12.13]
Related Posts
Activism, Academia and Black Community Struggles
Acknowledging Community Expertise
Dr Graham Smith: 3 items. Better awareness law courses, law school acknowl’ blk comm expertise, better dialogue w/comm. pic.twitter.com/J4iQUsodGe
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
This will call for interdisciplinary co-produced research with communities, especially with local BAME communities.
Related Post
Graham Smith: Just got embarrassed, Graham kindly spotlit me briefly4 my contribution to the team. Lemn Sissay bursary #blacklawyersmatter
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Graham Smith: Black lawyers matter will be working across law sector to improve employment chances. Also collab w/MMU
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Lemn Sissay Bursaries
Isabelle Cox: Explaining the bursaries. Applications can only be made post UCAS application. There will be an access day. Tailored support. pic.twitter.com/lPMGqETxzI
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Isabelle: We want to raise the level of engagement&partnership with the uni. Want open up Uni resources to the community #blacklawyersmatter
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Isabelle: We want to be as open as possible to the BAME comms across Manchester.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Lemn Sissay: I am honoured to put my name to this bursary. We have a black chancellor and a female VC, this is radical. pic.twitter.com/EGaqEFOpx2
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Isabelle Cox: This scheme gives us a space to discuss race. This is the only law based scheme in the country.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
This will need a prioritised forum for intersectional critical race scholarship for this to happen meaningfully.
Related Research
Stephanie Lee talking about Widening Participation at UoM pic.twitter.com/1dAGPrk2de
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Terry from Reclaim talking about their relationship with University of Manchester. pic.twitter.com/FGpyEAt4Ao
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Intersectional experiences of racial discrimination and the need for further interdisciplinary research
Why are the bursaries only aimed at black men. Graham: Black men are the most under-rep’d in the Law School.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Isabelle: Black men exp racism differently to black women, hence disproportionately fewer numbers of black men.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Isabelle: Black men are applying but not all getting entry requirements, so much support and guidance is needed.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
Intersectional critical race scholarship on the gendered nature of racialisation to form what bell hooks calls patriarchal terrorism would be useful to explore and understand in this context.
Isabelle:No age limit for the bursary. Workshops for mature learners and another for school leavers
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Stephanie: Manchester access programme get two grades lower bc they recog’ A levels not always good predictors of academic success.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
An audience member expressed alarm at the prospect of lowering grades via the Manchester Access Programme (MAP) for prospective BAME candidates and wondered whether this would disadvantage them in their consequent academic studies within the academy.
Dawn Edge: MAP is not a deficit. It is not a level playing field so MAP can help build social capital to equip them to do well at unis.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
The deficit model that is often applied to BAME communities, where assets are (un)consciously ignored, can often be internalised by BAME communities, themselves:
Audience member: We need to address internalised racism. We need to get over the taboo.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
However
Isabelle: Other unis don’t have the same problems as UoM, other unis like MMU are more diverse (they have their own problems)
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Tunde: As black communities we need to decide what you want to do early so that you can prepare and get what is needed in advance. pic.twitter.com/ESmoEfxyCt
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
A whiff of the Politics of Respectability or doing what is necessary to succeed in the system?
Tunde: Confidence is a major barrier to employment for ppl not from white middle class background. Job placements are crucial for this
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Kyle from Black Solicitors Network: Not just about black lawyers but they engage with the “pale, stale and male”. pic.twitter.com/PPLb2jcpLq
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Kyle: Giving our graduates the opp2 meet other forms and chambers. Building social networks and building confidence. 4 events.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Kyle: Rose tinted glasses from grads about getting jobs need to be removed (gently). Social capital is needed to progress.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
This is a question about the perceived value of the social and cultural capital already held by BAME communities. Despite their rich social and cultural capital networks, BAME communities still appear to have challenges benefiting from them in institutions that privilege whiteness. This raises important fundamental questions about the specific role of education in terms of BAME citizenry.
Related Research
Clennon, O. D. (2017) ‘We Don’t Need No Education. (Unless You’re Black). De-Colonised Education as a Tool for Political Activism’. In The Polemics of CLR James and Contemporary Black Activism (pp. 83-108). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-47548-6_5
Clennon, O.D. (2014) ‘Making Education a Priority: Where do we go from here? Towards a Community-Led Approach to Education ‘in Clennon, O. (ed.). Alternative Education and Community Engagement: Making Education a Priority. (pp. 122 – 134) Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan DOI: 10.1057/9781137415417.00010
Dawn Edge: Bursary enabling ppl to take advantage of extra curricula activities so that they don’t have to work outside uni so much.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Not level playing fields. Level of privi of white priv of male is astronomical. So don’t worry about bursary and targeting.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
The Lemn Sissay bursaries can play a crucial role in enabling the BAME student to create additional social capital networks that are valued by the academy and beyond, as many from more socio-economically privileged backgrounds already do.
UoM is to be commended for the access course. More work needs to be done with primaries and wider communities. Audience member.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Socio-legal consciousness
Community must see the relevance of the law2 the comms in everyday lives. Audience member. YESS: This requires proper community research.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Charles Crithlow: We need a legal consciousness. The law affects every1. Lammy’s review not new but important to highlight diff of treatment pic.twitter.com/Q0HcCBQi9M
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Charles Critchlow: This is much more about the law school but comm activists need to keep the university honest.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Charles Crichlow: The bursary needs to stay on course and not disappear. Need to hold Uni to account.
— Revelation Kollektiv (@revkollektiv) September 13, 2017
Commentary
Following on from Freirian ideas around a critical pedagogy that examines the role foundational role of education in educating and shaping citizens, Esther Stanford’s concept of socio-legal consciousness follows a similar line of thought. To emphasise this point about community relevance and accountability, audience members suggested that helping the community to set up their own legal advice centres (i.e. not university-led centres) would be a more effective way of building community capacity and acknowledging community expertise (this raises important questions around how we can encourage our BAME graduates to play a part in community building). This idea, of course, leads us back to the vexing conundrum of community-university partnerships, the power dynamic and sometimes conflicting agendas of both sets of communities……
Related Research
Clennon, O.D. (2020) Scholar activism as a nexus between research, community activism and civil rights via the use of participatory arts, The International Journal of Human Rights Vol 24, No. 1, 46 – 61, DOI: 10.1080/13642987.2019.1624535
Clennon, O.D. (2017) ‘Scholar Activism as a Nexus between Research and Community Activism via the use of Participatory Arts’ Paper presented at: Activist Scholarship in Human Rights: New Challenges. School of Advanced Study, London, 28th June
Trackbacks/Pingbacks